A checagem de fatos no Brasil: uma abordagem semiótica
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This thesis aims to determine whether the confrontation between misinformation and
fact-checking during the Covid-19 pandemic has led to a consistent improvement in
the critical skills of fact-checking journalists. The theoretical framework is based on
Charles Sanders Peirce’s pragmatism, which posits that through semiosis, the
evolution of logical interpretants—and consequently, of thought—can occur via the
scientific method. The central hypothesis is that, in the interpretative processes
surrounding the confrontations between misinformation and fact-checking, certain
limitations arise that hinder the consistent improvement of the critical capacity of
professional fact-checkers. This hypothesis is further divided into three subhypotheses, aligned with Peirce’s categories of phaneroscopy. First, we propose that
the lack of transparency regarding the origin of misinformation—whether robotic or
human—impacts the verification process, hindering journalists' perceptual
understanding of the qualitative constitution of the news. Second, we suggest that the
tension between the insistence on accurately depicting facts and the "packaging" of
news by journalism, coupled with the commercial and political interests of factchecking networks, creates conflicts in journalists' interpretative processes regarding
the relationship between facts and news. Finally, we hypothesize that robotic influence
and working conditions limit the potential expansion of critical skills. To empirically test
these hypotheses, we analyzed 20 pieces of content produced by the fact-checking
agencies Aos Fatos and Lupa, using Peirce’s analytical framework, and conducted
interviews with eight journalists involved in these productions. Our findings indicate
that, although the fact-checks do not explicitly address the use of bots, journalists
acknowledge the influence of qualisigns associated with robotic operations on their
perceptual judgment. These qualisigns could serve as a starting point for deeper
investigations, potentially expanding the understanding of the misinformation
phenomenon. Additionally, we observed that journalists prioritize dicent indexical
sinsigns to convey certainty rather than doubt, and through collateral experience, they
strive to approach the dynamic object. This reflects an ethical concern for raising
readers' awareness of existing misinformation processes. The content adheres to a
journalistic writing style that applies standard journalistic criteria and is sponsored by
Silicon Valley companies. The interviewed professionals confirmed that they use these
journalistic criteria to select which content to fact-check and how to phrase their
findings. However, they asserted that their association with Meta does not influence
the content they choose to verify or the manner in which they conduct their factchecking; rather, Meta provides a platform where misinformation processes can be
identified. They also noted that other tools are used for this purpose. Finally, the
interviews revealed that there is a continuous practice of self-criticism and peer critique
among the journalists, and although there are no formal evaluation seminars, daily
reflections enable them to refine their verification methods and content presentation
practices.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

