A prova em vídeo no júri do sistema criminal brasileiro: um olhar sobre sua aplicabilidade no âmbito do tribunal de justiça do estado do Rio de Janeiro
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This study aims to analyze the influence of video evidence on jurors’ perceptions in
cases tried by the Jury Court. It seeks to understand the relationship between the use
of this type of evidence and judicial outcomes, considering its evaluation, application,
and the interpretative variations to which it is subject. The methodology adopted was
qualitative research, through a case study from the Court of Justice of the State of Rio
de Janeiro, where video evidence was present throughout the evidentiary phase and,
more prominently, during the jury trial session. The analysis focused on the procedural
acts of the case, particularly regarding the presence — or absence — of video
evidence in the parties’ statements. The specificities of the case were examined,
highlighting the relevance of each statement in relation to the audiovisual content
presented. This approach enabled a deeper understanding of the implications and
impact of videographic evidence in judicial proceedings, especially in cases involving
jury trials. The theoretical framework emphasizes not only the complexity and
subjectivity inherent in interpreting videos as objective representations of facts, but
also the lack of preparedness in handling this type of evidence. Furthermore, the study
presents a historical overview of the jury system, with emphasis on its characteristics
in civil law and common law systems. Considering the growing use of videographic
evidence, driven by technological advancements, it is essential to critically analyze
how the Brazilian judiciary is managing this evidentiary resource. The findings indicate
that, despite the presence of video recordings in the case files, there is a lack of
discussion about them in procedural documents. Additionally, during the jury trial,
video evidence is used without any formal or standardized procedures, hindering its
interpretation.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

