Privacidade à exaustão: efeitos e fundamentos da regulação de atividades com dados pessoais
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
The Brazilian data protection law is strongly influenced by the theoretical and normative
perspectives that underlie the European General Data Protection Regulation. This influence can
be perceived in the definition of personal data and in the openness of the semantic content of
this concept, as well as in the fact that both norms are structured upon a set of principles. The
Brazilian General Data Protection Regulation (LGPD) enunciates to be founded upon and
aimed to protect several fundamental principles, which means it must fulfill the task of
balancing them by protecting the different dimensions of freedom they encompass. This study
aims at evaluating if, and to which extent, LGPD is capable of promoting balance between those
principles in a desirable form. In order to accomplish this, grounded theory has been
implemented, in conjunction with a phenomenological approach, to formulate the hypothesis
that the right to privacy is disproportionately embedded in the core foundations of LGPD. This
has led to an analysis which involves taking into consideration the foundations and objectives
of data protection regulation, as well as its effects, starting from the observation of the
phenomena it is intended to work upon. The objective of this approach is to better apprehend
how the data protection regulation framework might work in order to achieve constitutional
objectives and promote an adequate balance amongst them, considering the major importance
of data treatment activities in contemporary economy. The study starts with a short discussion
on the role of Law in establishing and altering social relations, especially in light of the possible
interactions between the Law and other fields of knowledge. Some of the most common ways
of conceptualizing data protection problems and regulation are also part of the discussion. The
study then analyses the concepts of personal data and of information, as well as its functions in
the regulatory framework, and moves to evaluate subjective perspectives of control information
and how data protection regulation might or might not work to provide control in different
stages of information use. At last, some of the implications of data protection regulation to
personal data markets are exposed and discussed, especially in light of discoveries that show
increased market concentration as a result of such regulation. It was possible to conclude that
the theoretical foundations of Brazilian data protection regulation lead to a kind of intervention
that is incapable of effectively approaching and dialoguing with contemporary data treatment
activities, which results in poor outcomes for data subjects and treatment agents, as well as for
the consistency of data protection theory regulation. The conclusions leave several perspectives
open for discussion and research, such as investigations regarding the potentialities of
multimodal argumentation in providing better choice-conditions for data subjects; possibilities
regarding the structuring of arrangements that provide more meaningful power to data subjects,
especially in the later stages of information use; the considering of regulatory and economic
structures that favor power dispersion in technology and data markets.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

