Ausência de presunção de legitimidade e de veracidade dos autos de infração exclusivamente lastreados na declaração do agente público autuador e preclusividade probatória da efetiva comprovação do ilícito no respectivo processo administrativo sancionatório: uma análise sistêmica do artigo 280, § 2º, do Código de Trânsito Brasileiro
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
The purpose of this monograph is to demonstrate, on the one hand, that traffic
violation notices (AITs) exclusively backed by the declaration of the public agent responsible
for the infraction do not enjoy the classic administrative attributes of presumption of
legitimacy and veracity, and, on the other hand, that the absence of effective proof of the
alleged violation, by the member of the National Traffic System (SNT), when the
administrative sanctioning process is initiated, implies, as a rule, the loss of the possibility for
the Public Administration to produce evidence about the alleged infraction at a later time.
From a material point of view, the elaboration of this work is justified both in terms of the
difficulty and/or impracticability of the accused person to oppose, with a robust evidentiary
complex, the state accusation based solely on the public faith of the supervisory agent, and in
due to the significant collection of revenue from the imposition of fines, with a possible
distorted use of that type of assessment in order to achieve, by oblique means, an eminently
collection scope to the detriment of the punitive-pedagogical. From the procedural aspect, this
investigation is necessary due to the existence of both regulatory gaps in the scope of the
administrative transit process, and the multiple general procedural discipline of States and
Municipalities in matters of Administrative Law, potentially giving rise to state abuses and
illegality, as well as unequal treatment to the detriment of those administered depending on
the corresponding sanctioning entity and the location where the alleged violation was
committed. For the investigative approach, the critical-dialectical and literary and
jurisprudential review methods were adopted and, as theoretical references, the doctrines of
neoconstitutionalism and legal post-positivism. It was observed that article 280, paragraph 2,
of the Brazilian Traffic Code (CTB), in the part in which it authorizes the proof of the traffic
violation based on the mere declaration of the public agent, is systemically inadmissible in the
current legal system, because it contradicts the Constitution of the Federative Republic of
Brazil of 1988 (CRFB/88), and confronts relevant homeland doctrine and jurisprudence
relating to the integrated domains of Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure and Sanctioning
Administrative Law. It was also found that, after the advent of the “new” Civil Procedure
Code (CPC), established by Law No. 13.105/15, supplementary and subsidiary applicable to
the situation under examination, it does not seem possible, as a rule, to effectively prove the
traffic infraction at a time after the initiation of the respective sanctioning administrative
process, mainly in the form of Resolution No. 918/22 of the National Traffic Council
(CONTRAN), given the violation not only of duties of good faith and procedural preclusive
rules on the production of documentary evidence. It was concluded that the first part of § 2 of
article 280 of the CTB was unconstitutional and legally inadmissible, as well as, as a rule,
probative preclusivity concerning the administrative-contentious action of the Executive
Branch in the traffic area, despite the (still) timid existence of procedural norms in this sense.
Description
Keywords
Presunção de legitimidade e de veracidade , Auto de infração de trânsito , Preclusão probatória , Processo administrativo sancionatório , Código de Trânsito Brasileiro , Presumption of legitimacy and veracity , Traffic infraction notice , Probative estoppel , Sanctioning administrative process , Brazilian Traffic Code
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

