O eixo de oralidade em materiais didáticos: por uma defesa do oral autônomo
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This dissertation is the result of an action research study (Thiollent, 2011) conducted within the
context of the Professional Master’s Program in Letters – PROFLETRAS – at the Federal
University of Juiz de Fora. The research aims, in general, to discuss the work with orality in
basic education. To this end, the objective is to analyze the activity sequences involving oral
genres in the teaching material of Colégio Tiradentes of PMMG (CTPM), identifying to what
extent the adopted workbook aligns with the autonomous oral approach proposal. In addition
to this analysis, the study seeks to investigate signs of language capacity development by
comparing the initial and final productions of video reviews created by 7th-grade students from
the institution. The initial productions were carried out after the activities proposed by the
school's adopted teaching material, while the final ones were produced following the
development of a customized teaching resource by the teacher-researcher, based on the
diagnosis of the first productions. These activities comprise the Pedagogical Notebook that
accompanies this dissertation. The research is based on the language perspective of SocioDiscursive Interactionism (Bronckart, 2006), reflections on the teaching of autonomous orality
(Dolz, Schneuwly; Haller, 2004; Cavalcante, 2007; Cristóvão, 2013; Magalhães, 2021;
Marcuschi, 2004), and the concept of language capacities (Cristóvão, Stutz, 2011; Dolz, 2004).
Initially, the research focused on analyzing the oral genres present in the aforementioned
teaching material, revealing that, among the studied stages, there was little emphasis on the
constitutive aspects of orality. We found that the genres listed for study in the material presented
gaps, in view of the autonomous oral perspective, in the stages that make up the orality section
in the collection. The material works with 8 oral genres. Of these, only 25% (Journalistic
Interview and Oral Review) present a model text and this occurs in only one of the stages
developed for the systematization of the genres. In the genre preparation stage, only the Radio
Spot – 12.5% – presented an approach considered satisfactory regarding the aspects of orality
such as kinesics, linguistics, paralinguistics and extralinguistics. This value is repeated in stage
3, production, since only the Podcast genre for scientific dissemination brings, in the
systematization of the genre, an approach to the aspects of orality. Through the analysis of the
initial productions—created after the application of the video review sequence presented in the
students’ teaching material—and the final productions—developed after the application of
activities from the material designed by the teacher-researcher—it was possible to compare
data. The results suggested that students showed signs of progress, particularly in multisemiotic
language capacity, which encompasses operations related to the constitutive aspects of orality.
The data indicate that the indexes for the multisemiotic capacity that involved the use of
background and music in the production of video reviews jumped, respectively, from 1 student
(8.3%) who was concerned with the initial recording environment to 6 students (50%), as well
as 91.3% of the students who had not planned to use background music in the first text and we
advanced the data to only 2 students (16.6%) who continued not to use music in their video
reviews.However, in other capacities, such as action and discursive capacities, the data did not
show significant changes, as these operations involved aspects that were already consolidated
among the students from the first production. Regarding the capacities of signification and
linguistic-discursive aspects, the data evolved progressively, as the final texts presented overall
better indicators compared to the initial ones. Thus, besides aiming to contribute to the
development of students’ language capacities, as evidenced by the research results, this study
also seeks to promote the teaching of autonomous orality, which remains largely overlooked in
linguistic theory and teaching materials in Brazil and is only marginally addressed in the
analyzed collection. Furthermore, our goal is to discuss ways in which teachers can reinterpret
mandatory teaching materials, making the work with orality more legitimate and contributing
to their continuous professional development.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

