Exhaustivity, linguistic prediction and integration: it-clefts and 'only' sentences
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This research investigates sentences with the adverb ‘only’/‘só’ and it-clefts/clivadas totais, in
English and in Brazilian Portuguese (BP). There is consistent evidence that these focus
markers (Kiss, 1998; Paterson; Liversedge; Underwood, 1999; Liversedge et al, 2002;
Zimmerman, 2004; Filik et al, 2009; Carlson, 2015) convey exhaustivity through different
processes (Horn, 1981; Rooth, 1992; Krifka, 1999; Drenhaus; Zimmerman; Vasishth, 2011;
Carlson, 2014; Lignani; Fonseca, 2023). Exhaustivity is the semantic effect whereby a
focused element in a sentence excludes all other alternatives to make that sentence true
(Rooth, 1992; Krifka, 1999). Two types of experiments were designed to compare
exhaustivity violations for clefts and ‘only’-structures: a) three Likert tests (Likert, 1932) –
AJTs (in English, tasks 1 and 2; in BP, task 3); and b) two eye-tracking tasks (one English and
one in BP). Our hypotheses were that: 1) exhaustivity violations in
‘only’-sentences/'só’-sentences' are less acceptable than in it-clefts/clivadas totais; 2) clefts
are more sensitive to context integration than sentences with the adverb. In the AJTs, there
were sets of stimuli in four conditions: exhaustive/non-exhaustive ‘only’-sentences
(‘Yesterday, only Anna brewed coffee and pastries too’/‘Yesterday only Anna brewed coffee
and Olivia did too’); and exhaustive/non-exhaustive clefts (‘Yesterday it was Anna who
brewed coffee and pastries too’/ ‘Yesterday it was Anna who brewed coffee and Olivia did
too’). In the eye-tracking experiment, we included context-sentences, displayed on previous
screens (‘Anna and Olivia run a busy bakery in London’). Results show that: 1)
‘only’-sentences were less accepted and elicited more regression-based measures than clefts;
2) non-exhaustivity decreased the acceptability of all sentences, and reduced the reading times
for adverb-sentences. Our findings corroborate the idea that exhaustivity relates to the truth
values in ‘only’-sentences (Rooth, 1992; Kriffa, 1999), whereas to pragmatic in clefts
(Drenhaus; Zimmerman; Vasishth, 2010; Onea, 2019). We argue that exhaustivity in clefts
engage prediction-by-production (Pickering; Gambi, 2018), in which comprehenders simulate
the speaker’s communicative intention (Destruel et al., 2015; Destruel; Tunnicliff, 2020).
However, exhaustivity in ‘only’-sentences is part of the core semantic content, unleashing the
fast, automatic process of prediction-by-association based on associations between words or
structures (Pickering; Gambi, 2018).
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

