Análise crítica do Tema 1199 do STF e a (ir)retroatividade da lei n° 14.230/2021: A evidenciação da ausência de um estatuto próprio do Direito Administrativo Sancionador
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares
DOI
Abstract
This Undergraduate Thesis critically analyzes the application of the principle of the
retroactivity of the most beneficial rule within the scope of administrative misconduct following
the reform introduced by Law No. 14,230/2021 and interpreted by the Supreme Federal Court
(STF) in the judgment of Theme 1199. Under the new legislation, liability for acts of
administrative misconduct now requires intent (dolo), statute of limitations periods were
altered, and sanctions were redefined, sparking intense debate on whether these provisions
could retroactively apply to benefit public agents convicted under the previous regime. In
Theme 1199, the STF established that retroactivity should only apply to cases that have not yet
reached a final and unappealable judgment (trânsito em julgado), thereby preserving definitive
convictions, even those based on negligent conduct (conduta culposa). Thus, it is observed that
there is a gap in the national legal system regarding the status of Sanctioning Administrative
Law, lacking a clear position on its functioning—specifically, whether it aligns more closely
with Criminal Law or possesses its own autonomy and rules. Based on bibliographic research
and an examination of the reasoning in the justices' votes, this study seeks to investigate whether
this limitation on retroactivity is compatible with the logic of Sanctioning Administrative Law
and constitutional principles such as legal certainty, the protection of legitimate expectations,
and proportionality. Furthermore, it evaluates the consistency of this understanding from the
perspective of Criminal Law principles, such as the penal tradition of full retroactivity of the
most favorable rule for the benefit of the defendant. It also analyzes the impact of such a
decision on the general interpretation of the functioning of Sanctioning Administrative Law.
Finally, the thesis discusses whether Theme 1199 represents an adequate harmonization
between substantive justice and institutional stability or whether it produces inequalities and
weakens the fight against administrative misconduct.
Description
Keywords
Improbidade administrativa , Retroatividade , Lei no 14.230/2021 , Direito administrativo sancionador , Tema 1199 do STF , Segurança jurídica , Estatuto , Direito Penal , Administrative misconduct , Retroactivity , Law no. 14,230/2021 , Sanctioning administrative law , STF theme 1199 , Legal certainty , Statute , Criminal law
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

